Happy Customers

Hear it from the people who know us best. Real reviews from real customers — the olive oil lovers, home chefs, and food professionals who've made Tastefully Olive part of their kitchen.

s
Tastefully Olive
sthankins75 Hankins

I recently had the pleasure of trying a bottle of The Blackberry Ginger Dark Balsamic Vinegar!! That is the most delicious balsamic I have ever had. Very good quality. We have eaten it on Stirfry, Greek Homemade yogurt and store bought yogurt, Grilled Chicken, Fried Chicken tenders, and Chicken Cordon Bleu‘s from Sam’s and salads it took them all to the next level. So Delicious I can’t wait to try different ones from Tastefully Olive!

T
Tastefully Olive
Therese Bertrand

I first discovered Tastefully Olive at a Farmer’s Market where I tasted and fell in love with their TexMex Olive Oil. It is full of flavor and spice, and I have loved using it for salads and for sautéing/grilling so many different things. I recently ordered some sample sizes of other oils and vinegars and have discovered that so many of their products have unique and complex, soft as well as robust flavors that cannot be found anywhere else. I have placed two orders with them over the past couple of weeks. I received a personal email from the company when one item was going to be delayed by a few days. Their customer service as weak as their products are superb! I will be a customer of theirs for a long time to come!

C
Tastefully Olive
Chi Rodriguez

I love the products. I use them for cooking and salads. The different flavors really enhance the flavor of the foods I cook and make eating fun. I love that I can get the products shipped to me fast. I would highly recommend Tastefully Olive.

D
Tastefully Olive
Donette Lane

The products are top notch and the shipping was so fast! I was also impressed with the packaging. We’ve had fun trying both the olive oil and all the flavored vinegars in salads and recipes. Will be a repeat customer!

K
Tastefully Olive
Kathy Johnstone

My order of 5 bottles of assorted olive oils arrived in 3 days. Awesome tasting light oils - great on crusty bread or drizzled on homemade pita bread "pizza" with sundried tomato, basil and mozzarella. Delicious to enjoy and gratifying to gift!

L
Tastefully Olive
Lora Belland

Tastefully olives is a perfect name for this Olive oil... I bought a bottle of the Italian seasoning infused oil for Dipping bread into. Delicious..... I also made a butter Board with the Italian seasoned oil. It's very flavorful and I'm a happy customer. We can't wait to try another one...

V
Tastefully Olive
Virginia Cochran

yummy stuff! shipped quickly and well packed so no breakage.

B
Tastefully Olive
Brandy Snell

Tastefully Olive is amazing! Not only is the product delicious this precious small family owned business goes above and beyond always! The owners become friends and truly put your needs in the forefront of all things!

R
Tastefully Olive
Rachael Afra

Melissa and Brian are the best, they helped me out with my order, and made it super perfect! They are very fast and very informative, and will love to work with them again! Love their selection! Thank you to you both!

S
Tastefully Olive
Sarah Liberti

They have the best balsamics and olive oils! Melissa is very easy to work with and these products have been a fantastic addition to our shop! Highly recommend giving them a try!

e
Tastefully Olive
eastin baker

Champagne white balsamic is so delicious! So is the dark chocolate balsamic!

R
Tastefully Olive
Raquel Buglehall

I mean, whoa. Couldn't buy just one. Adds a rich, fresh flavor to everything from salad to pasta to meats and fish.

L
Tastefully Olive
Lindsay N

Amazing products! Clean and fresh taste. The balsamics and olive oils are divine! Highly recommend

C
Tastefully Olive
Cindy Stuteville

Very helpful and knowledgeable. Samples are great

J
Tastefully Olive
Jacob Haley

This is truly an amazing product. The high polyphenol content in the olive oils makes for a very decadent experience. If you haven’t tried tastefully olive yet I highly recommend you do, you won’t find many domestic products that compare and you won’t be disappointed.

A
Tastefully Olive
Annette Mantia

These oils are amazing. I have reorder 3x. Adds such a different flavor to fish and chicken.
You will love this product

Z
Tastefully Olive
Zahra Somani

Loved working with Brian. He was patient and knowledgeable about his products. The oils themselves tasted incredible. So happy with the customer service and the merchandise and highly recommend!!

H
Tastefully Olive
Heather Cabo

I used the Herb Provenance Extra Virgin Olive Oil on my chicken for chicken Alfredo, and it smelt amazing and tasted amazing!! So amazing that my chicken didn’t even need extra seasonings!!!

B
Tastefully Olive
Brandi Hollibaugh

I’ve been using Tastefully Olive’s oils and vinegars for a couple of years now and absolutely love every product. My favorites are the Italian Seasoning EVOO and the Dark Traditional Balsamic. I use these in a roasted tomato sauce and it’s next level goodness. I highly recommend their products.

J
Tastefully Olive
Julie Bruno

This is a great Olive oil. The consistency is perfect and not too thin. The aroma and taste is perfect for everyday dishes not to mention all the health benefits it offers. Highly recommended! Thank you tastefully olive!

V
Tastefully Olive
Victoria Morgan

Their product is the best of the best! They put a lot of thought and love into their product. The taste tells all!

S
Tastefully Olive
Silvia Banocy

My family and I love the oils and balsamic vinegars, they are pure and delicious.

M
Tastefully Olive
McKenzie Muller

The truffle white balsamic is addictive, the truffle is strong and the flavor is amazing! I also got the honey ginger white balsamic, which was amazing mixed in with a summer peach salsa I made, and paired well with fresh mozzarella! My favorite of all was the Italian infused olive oil, amazing for cooking with and made a great gift for my friends who are learning how to cook! The quality of the olive oil is amazing, and the balsamics are all so tasty!

C
Tastefully Olive
Charles Dillehay

The best tasting olive oil you'll ever find! No oily after taste and very versatile!

M
Tastefully Olive
My French Recipe French cooking school

The olive oil is amazing. But wait until you try the balsamic!!

K
Tastefully Olive
Kayla Kaschak

I very much enjoyed the Tuscan Olive Oil it was very good on bread. Thank you so much for amazing quality and taste. Try this olive oil you won’t regret it!

Best olive oil I have ever tasted. Honestly did not think there was much difference from one olive oil to the other, but the taste of these are amazing. Not going back to the Costco brand anymore.

Frequently asked questions

Some questions and answers are automatically generated.

What does Tastefully Olive specialize in?
Tastefully Olive specializes in premium extra virgin olive oils and aged balsamic vinegars. Our catalog features infused oils with flavors like Italian seasoning, pesto, citrus, herbs, and spices, as well as specialty varietal oils from Italy and Greece. We also offer a diverse range of balsamic vinegars including fruit-infused, herb-infused, and gourmet dark and white varieties, plus a handmade olive oil soap.
What health benefits does your olive oil catalog feature?
Our oils are selected for their high polyphenol and antioxidant content, which support heart health, reduce inflammation, and promote overall wellness. Many products emphasize early harvest, cold-pressed production, and natural compounds like oleocanthal. The catalog as a whole reflects a focus on nutritious, health-conscious cooking that doesn't compromise on flavor.
Are your products suitable for a healthy eating lifestyle?
Yes. Our oils and vinegars are designed to support healthy, balanced eating. Infused oils are packed with antioxidants and polyphenols, while vinegars offer balanced acidity for dressings and marinades without excess calories. All products are made with premium, natural ingredients—no artificial additives—making them ideal for those prioritizing both nutrition and taste.
What materials and production methods are used across your oils?
Our olive oils are cold-pressed extra virgin oils sourced from premium groves in Italy and Greece. They are crafted using traditional production techniques to preserve flavor, freshness, and nutritional integrity. Balsamic vinegars are barrel-aged in oak, mulberry, chestnut, and juniper barrels to develop complex, balanced flavors.
Do you offer sets or curated collections?
Yes. We offer an Olive Oil Collection Bundle that lets you choose three bottles from our exquisite range of infused and specialty oils. We also provide Gift Boxes featuring carefully selected assortments of premium olive oils in beautifully packaged sets, ideal for gifting or personal exploration.
Who is Tastefully Olive for?
Our catalog serves a broad range of food lovers—from seasoned chefs and health-conscious home cooks to culinary beginners and those seeking gourmet gifts. Whether you're interested in Mediterranean cooking, healthy nutrition, entertaining guests, or exploring premium flavors, our products are designed to enhance your culinary experience at any skill level.
What flavor families and styles are available across your catalog?
Our catalog spans Mediterranean flavors (Italian seasoning, Greek seasoning, Tuscan herbs, Herb de Provence), citrus infusions (lemon, lime, blood orange, Meyer lemon), fruit-infused vinegars (berry, stone fruit, tropical), spiced and savory options (garlic, cumin, habanero, ginger), and luxury specialty flavors (truffle, bourbon, chocolate, honey). This diversity allows for creative pairings and versatile meal planning.
Are your products free from artificial ingredients?
Yes. Our oils and vinegars are crafted from natural ingredients with no artificial flavors or additives. All infusions use real fruits, herbs, and botanicals. Ingredients are selected for quality and authenticity, reflecting our commitment to premium, clean-label products.
Do you offer convenient sample or travel-sized options?
Yes. We offer 60ml sample bottles that are perfectly sized for travel, gifting, and exploring new flavors. These travel-friendly bottles allow you to enjoy our premium oils and vinegars on the go—whether at a picnic, in your office, or at a friend's home.
What makes your products different from standard flavored oils and vinegars?
Our products stand out for their commitment to quality, authenticity, and flavor complexity. Our oils use cold-pressed, high-polyphenol bases from premium varietal olives; our vinegars are barrel-aged for depth and balance. Each product is crafted with genuine infusions and natural ingredients—no shortcuts or artificial additives—ensuring superior taste and nutritional value compared to ordinary commercial alternatives.